I am a proponent of using the best materials that you can afford at that moment. Sometimes the best materials for the current job are an inexpensive sketchbook (CHEAP) from 5 Below. Sometimes it’s buying a single tube of Holbein watercolors or gouache at a time to build up a collection of the right materials for the job.

And maybe Holbein isn’t your favorite brand of watercolors, maybe you’re a  Winsor&Newton or Daniel Smith person. It’s not the brand it’s the quality of material we’re discussing here, and if you want to go on a deep dive of comparing brands and their quality there are many spaces to do that.

There are many spaces where you can get reviews (that aren’t sponsored) of materials to assess their quality and use. I have been quite skeptical of art material reviews over the last few years. Certain brands have flooded review spaces with free products and sponsored videos.

That is not what I’m writing about today.

I have been using oil pastels. I have been seeking out a more budget friendly alternative to Sennelier oil pastels. Because at about $5 a stick, I can’t afford that for myself or my groups. I have a generous budget, but not that generous. I spent some time diving deep on budget brand reviews.*

I found some quality alternatives and I’ve been using them and WHOA WHOA WHOA.

The key word to search for when buying oil pastels is soft- if you want that sennlier lipstick type feeling.

First up are the Mont Marte 48 pc set in a metal tin. I admit I purchased this for en plein air- the tin will stick to a pochade box. They are described as soft. The 48 color set is adequate for most sketching of portraits or landscapes. There aren’t quite enough greens but softer less garish greens can always be mixed.

Compared to Pentel or CrayPas or most of the budget brands I previously discussed, they are very soft. They are probably 2/3rd as soft as Sennelier. They are buttery and layer well and have nice vibrant colors. Think cold chapstick instead of lipstick.

I like them quite a bit. I like that I can get a nice thick layer and that as they warm up in use they really work into the page. The colors are nice and mix as expected. The ultramarine blue and burnt sienna mix to form a really nice dark gray. They are capable of nice impasto effects.

A downside is that they have a bit more crumble to them- in the same way as CrayPas, they have a tendency to snap.

They have a bit of a waxy odor, which I find pleasant.

The other budget brand, on the higher end of budget friendly is Paul Rubens. (look for sales on this one. When I bought my set they were a few dollars more) These sticks are warm butter soft and layer well. The slightest pressure applies a large amount of pastel to the canvas. They produce a wonderful impasto effect. The colors are vibrant and are reported to be mostly lightfast and the actual pigments are labeled. The sticks don’t break unless you want them to.

These are a smidge harder than Sennelier pastels. They feel very similar. Image produced as part of @emmablockillustration Patreon Art Hang

I really  really like these and will be using them a lot. I think a few sets of these along with more sets of the Mont Marte will be what I stock the group space with.Image produced as part of @emmablockillustration Patreon Art Hang

There is one big downside to the Paul Rubens and that is a very strong odor. It smells a bit like used motor oil, turps, and old school printing ink. It’s not unpleasant (to me) but I could see many folks finding it VERY unpleasant. It smells mostly like used motor oil to me. I also found that some of the sticks were oozing or weeping oil. This seemed to mostly happen with the dark purples and blues. It was easily wiped off and the tray wiped clean. From one of my own photos. I’ve drawn this one a few times.

I do have one additional set on the way- Lightwish. I’ve been heard (via a YouTube review) that Lightwish is the Paul Rubens’ more budget friendly brand. Lightwish and Paul Rubens are 2 brands I give the side eye to when it comes to reviews on YouTube.

Anyway, we’ll see how those perform and I’ll write more.

*In disclosure, these were purchased through my work budget and for my job. A perk of my job is purchasing testing supplies and then getting to use them to determine if they will be good for the kids I work with.