I’ve read a few comments that people think the Field Notes Shelterwood edition won’t hold up to everyday wear and tear in a back pocket. I decided to carry a shelterwood in my back hip pocket, without a cover, until it falls apart. It’s now been 12 days.

The first week was uneventful. So far, I find the wear and tear on the book minimal at best. The creases are the only damage that is noticeable. There is discernable wear on the corners and edges of the book, but again you need to look close for this wear.

Here are a few pics of the Shelterwood after 2 weeks in my sweaty back pocket.

I’m on a pencil kick lately, (as if you hadn’t noticed) and I recently purchased the Pencils.com mixed palomino pencil pack. This is a pack that contains a selection of 9 of the most popular Palomino pencils. Included in this pack are one each of: Blackwing, Blackwing 602, Blackwing Pearl, Orange Palomino Premium HB Eraser Tipped, ForestChoice #2 (FSC-certified), (the rest are all made in the USA) Green Prospector #2 , Natural Prospector #2, Orange Golden Bear #2, and Blue Golden Bear #2. I have previously reviewed the Blackwing and the Blackwing 602, which are both great pencils for sketching. I hope to review all of the pencils in the set but for now this is a general review of the set.

The Blackwing pencils included are obviously the high end of the lot. As such they perform flawlessly and will not disappoint in appearance or use. Read my review of the Black wing and the 602. The orange Palomino Premium HB with an eraser top sits in the premium grouping. Without a complete review, it’s a very nice pencil.

The next group of pencils are the middle level, the Palomino Prospector and Golden Bear. Their bright colors and smooth finish are also very nice. I really enjoy the clear finish on the naturally colored Prospector. It’s darn near perfect. The lead in all of this group of pencils is similar. The pencils in this grouping will also be satisfying.

The final pencil is the Forest Choice. It’s a very nice pencil but not my favorite.

In terms of sketching, these pencils are mostly HB. So they are great for starting out a drawing but won’t give you a huge range of shades or deep darks. The Blackwings are an exception to this, as they are all softer and darker than an HB designation. I’d put them in the range of 2B.

After doing a little rough math, the price for the 9 pack is not bad when you consider that buying a package of each of these pencils all together would cost about $90. It’s a great way to test out a great group of pencils without investing in 12-packs that you might not like. Overall these pencils won’t disappoint and it will help narrow down what you like, or don’t like, in a pencil.

I hope to get reviews of the rest of the pencils in the next few weeks.

Continue reading →

Another extruded pencil mentioned on the Erasable podcast is the Staedtler Wopex. These are $5 for 18 pencils at Staples. That’s 28 cents a pencil.

These pencils are nice bright lime green in color with a silver imprint on one side. The other side has a barcode and assorted other info printed. The silver doesn’t flake off or scrape off. The black barcode is easily scraped off with a fingernail. The lime green coating is soft and can be marked with a fingernail. These are slightly smaller, roughly 1 millimeter thinner than a regular pencil. Again like the allXwrite it does not fit into a bullet pencil. The ferrule fits the pencil well and the eraser is white plastic.

In terms of use, this pencil has a waxy feel. It’s not slick but unlike other extruded pencils this feels more like a regular pencil to me. Additionally, the pencil is stiff and not flexible like older extruded pencils. It does not like the KUM long point sharpener. Rather, it works best in a sharpener that produces a shorter point. The points are somewhat crumbly but not overly bad. When sharpening the plasticized wood peels off in long curls. It’s weird and rubbery feeling.

In use the pencil is perfectly average. It's nice and smooth without a hint of scratchiness. For writing, I found it to be relatively comfortable. After writing up case notes for a paper, my wrist, hand, and fingers were less sore than with the allXwrite.

For sketching this is a lightly colored pencil. It is not going to product nice deep darks, rather it does nice even shade of gray. I was able to get a nice variety of the lighter tones of gray. Again, I have to point out that this is a pretty average pencil in terms of color and lead. it’s a very pencil colored pencil. You are not going to get deep darks out of this pencil, no matter how many layers of pencil you put down or how hard you press.  

I did find myself sharpening this pencil pretty often while writing. Because it cannot be used in the long point sharpener I found myself have to get the wedge out to keep my point pointy. Unlike the allXwrite I didn’t feel like I was constantly writing with a blunt instrument, but it wore down quickly. though this pencil is supposed to last longer than other pencils, I’m not sure that’s the case. I’ll have to get a Palomino out to test against it.

On the whole, I liked this pencil for writing but not as much for drawing. It was a pretty blah and unresponsive pencil for sketching. For writing it works just fine and I’ll throw a few into my pencil cup to use for case notes and other various school duties. At 28 cents a pencil it’s not a bad choice for writing.

Continue reading →

I’ve been listening to some podcasts as I work on my papers and one of them that I’ve been listening to is Erasable, a podcast about pencils. One of the pencils that was mentioned was the Steadtler woodless allXwrite. It’s an extruded pencil with no wood case. They cost about $4 for 5 pencils.

The look of the pencil is very cool looking. It is graphite colored. Unlike most all graphite pencils it is not cased in plastic or lacquer. Rather the process and what is extruded creates something that doesn’t leave marks on your hand. The imprint is silver and the reverse side has a white print with the bar code. The pencil itself is slightly narrower than typical pencils, by about a millimeter. As a result it is not a candidate to be put into a bullet pencil . (Insert frowny face here.) The fit of the ferrule and the eraser is tight and looks great. All in all it’s a very good looking pencil. But looks alone won’t make me buy a pencil. Well, looks alone will get me to BUY the pencil, but I might not like it, or buy another pack.

In use, I found this pencil to be, in a single word, weird. The pencil feels plasticy in hand. But that isn't a problem, the problem is the drag as I write or draw. The tip is almost sticky on the page. To combat this I found myself using additional pressure, which didn't seem to stop the sticky feeling. The mark the pencil makes is lighter but the same color as a regular number two pencil. But at regular pencil writing pressure, it was light.

While drawing I was able to moderate my pressure to get a variety of shades, but I could NOT get deep darks. The maximum darkness available is not all that dark. For quick sketching or under sketches it would be fine. I would be worried about the plastic, wax and clay content and if acrylic would stick well. I have not had a chance to test this out.

The best way to describe the feel of this pencil is to compare it to a medium priced colored pencil. It has that same drag and feel.

Sharpening this pencil was also weird. It does not like the KUM long point sharpener. I was able to force it through but it took way more effort and the point was crumbly. I was better off using a KUM brass wedge sharpener that kept a shorter point. I did find that I was sharpening this pencil ALL the time. The point would chip off leaving me with a blunt point. Rotating the pencil as I wrote or drew didn’t help keep the point sharp for very long. Sharpening with a knife was possible but again, sharpening a long point was not very useful as the point would break off. While drawing I sharpened less, likely because I was using the blunted point to make specific marks.

Is is one I’d suggest for art journaling? Not really. It’s an interesting pencil but not that great for art or art journaling. As for writing, ehhh, I didn’t like it for that either. I used it to write up case notes for a paper and found it endlessly frustrating and by the end of writing 11 pages of composition page notes, my hand, fingers, and wrist were sore and tired. For 80 cents there are much better pencils out there. On a side note I did cut the ferrule and eraser off and fit it into my Stad one touch pencil holder, which made the pencil MUCH more comfortable. It still had that weird dragging sticky feel on the page and even WITH the holder I used more pressure than usual.

I tend to wax philosophic about higher end writing instruments while stating “You can make art with anything!” I also write more often about fountain pens, since fountain pens are a passion of mine and I enjoy using them I tend to shove that love into everyone’s face. In some sense I think that if you try a FP you’ll love it, but the truth is that sometimes, a ballpoint or rollerball pen will do just fine. My next few reviews are going to focus on the lower end of price spectrum, while one is for a fountain pen, it’s one I think is worth reviewing (but that’s next week.) This week it’s all about the cheap, old fashioned, clicking ballpoint pen. If you are of a certain age you remember a time when businesses handed out pens with their contact info on them. My Grandmother always kept a cup of them handy near her phone. Because we lived in the country and we frequented places that sold feed and seed a good number of them were for that sort of location. The gas company, gas stations, electric company, and other places handed these out. At one point you could order the Bic Clic or Papermate pens in school colors. These pens were ubiquitous. They were the business party favors from the 50s to the 80s. In the mid 80s everything switched over from the refillable click pen with a metal clip to the Bic Clic Stic. You can still find the old metal clip Bic Clic online, if you want to order 300 of them you can get them for about 75 cents each, less if you order more. Well I don’t have about $200 laying around to buy cheapo pens, but I did have $6.

Kikkerland, the company known for selling the SuckUk and as being the former districbutor of Moleskine in the US, sells “Retro Pens.” For about $6 (less if you have an artist and craftsman near you) you get 5 made in China old school style click pens. They arrive in a hard plastic box, that is useful for storing the unused pens.

The five pens are mixed colors of dusty blue, cream, grey, green and black. Each pen has 2 colors, again a nod to the fact that most of the advertising pens you could buy had 2 colors with an imprint on the bottom half of the pen. In the middle of each pen is a slim metal ring with a matte finish. The clip and knock are the same matte silver metal. The clip is printed KIKKERLAND. The plastic is smooth and shiny. I noted a few scuff on each pen from being tossed about in the plastic box, but nothing that I really cared much about, considering this is a $1.25 pen.

The point deploys via a satisfying click from the knock. The point itself has a very small amount of wiggle at the tip. It isn’t noticeable as I write and draw. The knock does flop around loosely after the tip is deployed, but not an issue if you aren’t a pen spinner or jiggler as you think. Again it’s just not noticeable if you are writing or drawing.

So, how does it write? Not bad. As far as cheap pens go, it could always be improved with a better refill. But straight out of the box it does okay in writing and drawing. It flows smoothly and evenly. It also has what I call the ability to create a “sensitive”line. Which means it responds to the pressure I use as I draw or write. Low pressure= light line higher pressure= darker line. For the style of drawing I’ve been doing this is very useful. The ink is nice and dark.  Do I think i’m going to be drawn to start taking class notes with this pen? Probably not. I’ll keep using my fountain pens and gel inks for class notes. I got these specifically to draw on the subway and train. For that purpose they are wonderful.

I have to say that the variety of colors is nice, especially if you are into matching your pen to your notebook/journal cover.

You can get these on Amazon . You can also buy retro or vintage pens on etsy. Sometimes the sellers have rehabbed the pens to be in working order, and others you can get a few pens that need work or a new refill. 
  You can get refills on amazon or almost any office supply store. These are new pens so I haven’t messed around with refills yet, but when I do, I’ll keep you updated.

I've been using one of these non-stop for a little over a week. I've been putting it through it's paces as my EDC pen and thus far it's performing admirably well. While it's not as tough as an all metal bodied pen, I'm decidedly NOT careful with it. It's been getting shoved into my back pocket with my notebook and sat on, walked around, and generally abused. It's really getting the ass end of the deal… Anyway, sophomoric humor aside. The point is a little scratchy at a couple of angles. If I rotate the pen, the scratchiness disappears. This is, I think a function of the cheap refill. Which I've used over half while nearly continuously writing or drawing over the last week. I suspect that in another week I'll have killed the refill. As I've learned, I use a lot of ink. I might have to go hit up the refill display at Bob Slate again…

Continue reading →

While I can say I've never been a big fan of the color that is Bay State Blue (BSB) I've never been a detractor either. Even though it stained my pen, sink and hands I shrugged my shoulders andfigured whatever, to each their own. I like Private Reserve Electric DC blue. Not everyone likes that.

I ordered one sample of BSB in 2011 and used it prretty much straight away in a Noodler's Nib Creeper pen. I  used most of it in a Rhodia Webbie. I noted that there was some show through and some bleed through, but not all of the time. I used it for journaling and for drawing.

Like my Fisher Space pen in red, it ghosts after a few years. What is ghosting? When an ink migrates through to the reverse side of the page and you can see a "ghost" of the image on the front. The ghosting with the Space pen red was dispersed and faded, very pink. Also each line had a halo of ink that had migrated away from the original lines. With the BSB The migration to the reverse of the page is intense and amazing. The original drawing or writing can be viewed (or read) in detail. I can see a slight haloing on the fron to fhte page. If I had filled both sides of the page with BSB it would no longer be legible.

Can anyone else report this effect?

I realize that I’ve been writing about the BanditApple Carnet notebooks for a year or more and I haven’t reviewed them. It’s time to fix that.

The BanditApple Carnet notebooks are available in 3 sizes: Handy (MTN size 8.5×4.33inches), PeeWee (3.5×5.5 inches), pocket book (4x6inches). They also offer a planner in the peewee size. The covers are available in red, green, tan and black. Inside you can get plain, lined, or gridded paper. This review is on the peewee plain, but they use the same paper inside all their notebooks. Some of the books have rounded corners and some do not. My most recent plain notebook with a tan cover had square corners. My previous black PeeWee had rounded corners.

They feature a machine stitched binding using heavy weight cotton thread. I’ve been using the PeeWee size for a couple of years now and can say that the binding doesn’t look worn on any of my notebooks. It doesn’t matter if I’ve carried them in a cover or naked in my back pocket. The notebooks are very sturdy and stand up to abuse. The covers have a lovely texture and the color is sold  throughout. The cover is plain, featuring no adornments, not even a company logo, rather that info is on the clear plastic sleeve that makes up the notebook’s package.

Inside the notebook are 64 pages of 80gsm “heritage” paper that is off white in color. I don’t know what heritage means other than “awesome.” The paper handles everything I throw at it from fountain pens to brush pens to light watercolor washes, and has the additional benefit of being lovely with pencil. This paper is amazing sketching paper for the price. I rarely get any bleed through. I’ve got one Japanese calligraphy brush pen that soaks through, but it soaks through every paper I own. It is also rare that I’m able to see through to what I’ve drawn or written on the other side.  The paper isn’t super smooth but gives just enough feedback with a pen to be nice. With a brush pen the pages don’t wrinkle, but with light watercolor washes they wrinkle a small amount. Not enough that i’m bothered by it, but I mention it because I know some people are bothered by wrinkles.

The big drawback to these notebooks is that they are only carried by a few online vendors and I’m not able to find them in person at all. Goulet Pens carries them as does Zeller writing company. But, it looks like Zeller has them on clearance. You can order a sample directly from the company in Seoul here. Turnaround time is roughly 3 to 6 weeks, I had mine in 4. For $3 you can’t go wrong.

The price for the 64 page PeeWee notebook is $3.50USD, roughly the same price as a Field Notes or Moleskine Cahier but with significantly better paper and more pages.

If you are outside of the US you can find a vendor on this list.

Continue reading →